Where's The Proof?

By Brianna Austin

                                                                            

I received an email from Robert Knight about a post I made and I felt compelled to respond. 

January 25, 2006 

First, I would like to thank you for taking the time to respond to my earlier email. In most cases I don’t get responses, and of those I do get it is simply to tell me that they are right, I am wrong, and if I have any doubts that I should buy their book.  

I should note that Transsexuality and homosexuality communities are varied and diverse onto themselves. I agree that there is not yet any definitive all encompassing proof, however, the book by  Zhou J.-N, Hofman M.A, Gooren L.J, Swaab D.FA Sex Difference in the Human Brain and its Relation to Transsexuality (1997 ) states, “gender identity develops as a result of an interaction between the developing brain and sex hormone.  It goes on to present evidence that there is a physical difference in certain areas of the brain between M > F transsexuals and men.   

Researcher Brian Mustanski PhD (a psychologist at the University of Illinois at Chicago) in regard to homosexuality said: “It builds on previous studies that have consistently found evidence of genetic influence on sexual orientation.” (Fox News ,com Jan 28, 2005

You make a blanket statement that “ Homosexuality is a detour from natural, God-given sexuality,” even though it is found throughout the animal kingdom.  So, where is your scientific evidence? 

The difficulty I have with some anti-gay, anti-trans advocates is when someone like Peter LaBarbera makes broad statements about an entire community of people based on his clandestine visit to a few underground seedy bars.  If I went to all the major cities and went to the seedy underground straight sex bars, wouldn’t I find the same? 

There are 40,000 post operative transsexuals living in the United States, and most you would never find in a seedy bar, or even recognize as a transsexual if you passed them on the street.  They are secretaries, doctors, authors, recording artists, models, and a wide array of blue and white-collar workers. Having previously been a nightlife journalist for New York City for four years, I mixed with a wide variety of people from all different groups, including the GLBT and mainstream. From my experience each has their share of the good, the bad and the ugly.   

When you shoot me a laundry list of why we as a society should steer people away from being who they are, you can spin that info anyway that suits your need.  Depression, anxiety and suicide are high in the GLBT community, true. But if you researched further you would learn that most of them can’t deal with a society, friends or family that denies them the right to choose their own life and be who they are and are forced to live a lie. 

You may get a better understanding of my thoughts here: 

http://www.brieaustin.com/Essays/divorcerates.htm, or here: 

http://www.briannaaustin.com/Food4thought/essays/essays.html 

If you would like to respond I am always interested and willing to listen.  

Sincerely, Brianna Austin

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As always, be happy, be safe, and think pretty.
Brianna Austin
                                                                                                       


  1. Start a discussion or make a comment about this editorial at the message boards.
  2. Email Me. (Please note if you choose to remain anonymous.)

© 2004 - Brianna Austin - All Rights reserved

Insights      Fiction     True Stories    Poems

Home